Archives
 By  Staff Reports Published 
7:33 pm Saturday, August 17, 2002

Pushing tort reform

By Staff
August 11, 2002
Democratic state Rep. Walter Robinson of Bolton has summed up the debate in Mississippi over tort reform.
A funeral director and member of a legislative panel studying the issue, ostensibly in preparation for a special session of the Legislature later this year, Robinson told The Associated Press last week that lawmakers need to do all they can to keep doctors in the state. But, he said, lawmakers should move cautiously because he doesn't want to limit people's rights to sue if they or their family members are hurt.
You can't put a price on a mama in pain,'' Robinson was quoted as saying. Everybody is thinking about if it's the other fellow that's affected. Sometimes you need to look at it what if it's your family?''
That is precisely the type of emotional argument we have to get past if the law is to be truly fair and impartial. Isn't justice supposed to be blind? Aren't verdicts supposed to be based on evidence and the law? Aren't trials supposed to separate fact from fiction?
In a better civil justice system, jury verdicts would not be based on emotions of the moment and, thus, Robinson, perhaps unwittingly, has made a strong case for why tort reform is so essential to Mississippi's future.
Unfortunately, in the current civil justice climate, emotionalism rules, fed by a river of contentious ill will between two affected professions the law and medicine. Political emotions are running high and voters are trying to sort through it all.
Of all the subjects President Bush touched on during his few hours in Mississippi last week, the most politically volatile is tort reform. The president raised the profile of what some like to think is little more than a difference of opinion between rich doctors and rich lawyers.
It's more than that.
It's about fairness and, ultimately, justice blind unemotional justice.
And now that the president has elevated Mississippi tort reform squarely into the middle of the national political stage, the stakes are even higher. For a few weeks at least, restoring some sense of balance to a civil justice system that is running amuck may very well the central issue of the campaign in the 3rd Congressional District.
Both U.S. Rep. Ronnie Shows and U.S. Rep. Chip Pickering have positions on a central element of tort reform, capping non-economic damage awards. Shows is against it. Pickering is for it. Bush suggested a $250,000 cap on punitive damages and that's probably about right. Successful litigants could still recover actual damages.
Two predictions in the wake of the Bush's comments:
Shows will get a lot more money from trial lawyers and their affiliated groups who adamantly oppose tort reform.
Pickering's campaign will get a lot of money from people and political action committees that support tort reform.
The election is Nov. 5
Reformers in Mississippi could not have found a more articulate messenger than a popular president He left no doubt which side he's on.
Whether the president's comments will have any impact on an expected special session of the Legislature later this year remains to be seen. But my guess is he brought the issue front and center in the minds of many Mississippians and their doctors and businesses. He explained why people suffer when doctors leave the state because of the high cost of medical malpractice insurance because of "junk" lawsuits.
It's a modern day domino effect, a vicious cycle that, ultimately, could leave many Mississippians without quality health care. Mississippi's current civil justice system is more likely to line the pockets of a handful of aggressive trial lawyers than it is to produce "justice."
Tort reform, particularly the issue of caps on punitive damage awards, need not be so contentious. It's pretty straightforward.
And, ultimately, business people who say they don't care to dirty their hands with politics for fear of alienating customers are nonetheless going to have to make a decision and take a stand either by their votes or by their silence.

Also on Franklin County Times
County school board adopts $52M budget
Main, News, Russellville, ...
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
September 17, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE Franklin County Schools has adopted a $52 million budget for fiscal year 2026, reflecting a $2.5 million increase over last year. The bud...
Judge denies YO status for Phinizee
Main, News, Z - News Main
Bernie Delinski For the FCT 
September 17, 2025
FLORENCE — Youthful offender status was denied Tuesday for a 17-year-old charged with the death of a 13-yearold during what authorities said was a rob...
RCS passes $43.3M budget
Main, News, Russellville
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
September 17, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE -- The city school board has approved a $43.3 million budget for the 2025-26 school year. Chief Financial Officer Lisa Witt said revenues...
Program tackles stress of caregiver burnout
News, Records, Russellville
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
September 17, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE -- Many people deal with caregiver burnout. Kids and Kin childcare partner Marquita Wilson presented a program at the Russellville Public...
Flavil Wayne McCaig
Obituaries
September 17, 2025
Flavil Wayne McCaig Sept. 12, 2025   Flavil Wayne McCaig, 82, of Russellville, passed away Sept. 12 at his residence. He was born March 3, 1943, to Au...
Cultura Garden Club begins its year with roses and plans for fall
Columnists, News, Opinion
HERE AND NOW
September 17, 2025
The Cultura Garden Club held its first meeting of the year. President Cheri McCain presided. She provided information on projects and programs for the...
We can’t afford to lose electric vehicle industry
Columnists, Opinion
September 17, 2025
In Alabama, we understand what it means to build things that matter. We’ve long been home to builders and winners – our steel won wars and built the s...
Firefighters, cadets honor 9/11 with stair climbs
News, Russellville
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
September 17, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE – Firefighters and RHS JROTC cadets participated in a stair climb in recognition of the 24th anniversary of 9-11. Sgt. Grant Tarascou and...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *