Columnists, Opinion, Scot Beard
 By  Scot Beard Published 
10:03 am Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Violence is the wrong reaction to health bill

By Staff
Scot Beard
Columnist
On March 21 the United States House of Representatives angered millions of Americans by passing the controversial health care reform bill by a vote of 219-212.
The bill, which had been the subject of heated debate for more than a year, barely limped through the House and anger would have been inevitable whether it passed or failed.
Unfortunately, some people reacted with acts of violence or threats of violence to members of Congress.
Bricks were thrown through windows at district offices and police in Pennsylvania arrested a man over the weekend for threatening to kill Rep. Eric Cantor of Virginia — he is the second highest Republican in the House.
There are many aspects of the legislation that should anger Americans — no matter if they are Republicans or Democrats — but acts of violence are not the answer.
About 46 years ago Congress passed legislation that was also highly unpopular — The Civil Rights Act of 1964.
While health care reform and civil rights are different issues, they were both divided the country.
The difference here is that the acts of violence, such as the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing, came before the legislation was enacted.
The violence cost countless lives, and ultimately was unsuccessful in stopping the legislation.
Worse, it left a wound on Alabama and other southern states that has been slow to heal and has not been forgotten to this day.
America does not need a similar wound in 2010 when there are so many other problems needing attention.
Fortunately there have not been any deaths yet related to the health care legislation, and hopefully there won’t be. Dissatisfaction should be shown at the voting booth, not at the end of a gun.
Acts of violence only makes the opposition seem desperate and hurts the cause more often than it helps.
Too many people died leading up to the legislation of 1964, if one person dies as the result of the legislation of 2010 it will be one too many.
Make your anger known with your brain at the voting booth, not with your muscle at your congressman’s house.

Also on Franklin County Times
Williams defeats Marbutt in Phil Campbell mayor’s race
News, Phil Campbell, Z - News Main
María Camp maria.camp@franklicountytimes.com 
August 27, 2025
PHIL CAMPBELL — Voters in Phil Campbell elected Greg Williams as mayor in Tuesday night’s municipal election.   Williams defeated Mayor Eddie Marbutt,...
Russellville PD spends $18.5K for computer upgrades
Main, News, Russellville
Russ Corey For the FCT 
August 27, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE — Police Chief Chris Hargett wasn’t necessarily ready to purchase more than a dozen new computers for his department, but a decision by t...
Red Bay freshman to compete in FFA national talent program
Main, News, Red Bay, ...
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
August 27, 2025
RED BAY — Freshman Kayeden Palmer will take her baton to Indianapolis, Indiana, this fall after being selected for the National Future Farmers of Amer...
Record $172K in grants awarded
Main, News, Russellville
Russ Corey For the FCT 
August 27, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE — Six Franklin County schools, the Franklin County Emergency Management Agency, five volunteer fire departments, and other organizations ...
Deck is completed for Highway 247 bridge
Main, News, Red Bay
Russ Corey For the FCT 
August 27, 2025
RED BAY — A new $3.3 million bridge being built over Little Bear Creek northeast of Red Bay on Alabama 247 continues to take shape. The bridge was clo...
Terry-Warner joins Extension Service
News, Russellville
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
August 27, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE - Katherine Terry-Warner still remembers her first field class in the Adirondack Mountains. It was part of her undergraduate studies at t...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *