Archives
 By  Staff Reports Published 
4:18 am Monday, December 13, 2004

Our View – What other papers are saying

By Staff
Clashing over sources, media and government both claim high motives.
In the federal courthouse in Washington on Thursday, lawyers will try to keep two reporters out of jail. A Justice Department special counsel is trying to find the source or sources who in 2003 leaked to the media Valerie Plame's CIA connection, a potential felony. For refusing to testify fully about their confidential sources, a federal district judge has ordered the imprisonment of Matthew Cooper of Time magazine (who wrote about the Plame leak) and Judith Miller of the New York Times (who didn't). Their attorneys will urge the appellate court to overturn the ruling.
The conflict – government officials demanding the names of confidential sources and reporters refusing to comply – is an American classic. And if Cooper and Miller lose their appeal, expect events to unfold according to a scenario that's been sacrosanct for at least 150 years. The two reporters will continue to refuse to testify about confidential sources. Keeping such secrets, they'll say, is a fundamental duty of journalism.
Next, unless the government backs down, comes incarceration. Held for contempt of Congress in 1848 over leaks related to a treaty with Mexico, New York Herald reporter John Nugent spent his days in an empty committee room and his nights at the home of the Senate's sergeant-at-arms. Nugent continued writing articles, puckishly datelined "Custody of the Sergeant-at-Arms."
Miller and Cooper won't be staying at anybody's home, but they can expect leniency of another sort. Uncooperative witnesses in federal grand jury investigations can be jailed for up to 18 months, but 5 1/2 months appears to be the record for an American journalist.
That's the term served by freelancer Vanessa Leggett, imprisoned in 2001 and early 2002 for refusing to testify in a Houston murder investigation.
Of the 18 journalists incarcerated between 1984 and 2000, according to a list compiled by the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, none was behind bars for more than three weeks, and nine were freed within a day. It's scant compensation for the loss of freedom, but Miller and Cooper can anticipate near-unanimous support from the rest of the media.
Even so, the familiar clash between government and media isn't just an empty ritual. Beneath their obstinacy, each side is seeking to vindicate a duty to seek the truth. And each side is adamant about its high motives: An uncooperative witness is an affront to "the rights and dignity of the House, and consequently of the people of the United States," Rep. Henry Ridgely declared in 1812. "This is really all about the readers," Miller said of her case in an interview with the New York Observer. "This is all about the public – the public's right to know."
The adversaries in these recurrent conflicts, it turns out, have a lot in common.

Also on Franklin County Times
County school board adopts $52M budget
Main, News, Russellville, ...
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
September 17, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE Franklin County Schools has adopted a $52 million budget for fiscal year 2026, reflecting a $2.5 million increase over last year. The bud...
Judge denies YO status for Phinizee
Main, News, Z - News Main
Bernie Delinski For the FCT 
September 17, 2025
FLORENCE — Youthful offender status was denied Tuesday for a 17-year-old charged with the death of a 13-yearold during what authorities said was a rob...
RCS passes $43.3M budget
Main, News, Russellville
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
September 17, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE -- The city school board has approved a $43.3 million budget for the 2025-26 school year. Chief Financial Officer Lisa Witt said revenues...
Program tackles stress of caregiver burnout
News, Records, Russellville
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
September 17, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE -- Many people deal with caregiver burnout. Kids and Kin childcare partner Marquita Wilson presented a program at the Russellville Public...
Flavil Wayne McCaig
Obituaries
September 17, 2025
Flavil Wayne McCaig Sept. 12, 2025   Flavil Wayne McCaig, 82, of Russellville, passed away Sept. 12 at his residence. He was born March 3, 1943, to Au...
Cultura Garden Club begins its year with roses and plans for fall
Columnists, News, Opinion
HERE AND NOW
September 17, 2025
The Cultura Garden Club held its first meeting of the year. President Cheri McCain presided. She provided information on projects and programs for the...
We can’t afford to lose electric vehicle industry
Columnists, Opinion
September 17, 2025
In Alabama, we understand what it means to build things that matter. We’ve long been home to builders and winners – our steel won wars and built the s...
Firefighters, cadets honor 9/11 with stair climbs
News, Russellville
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
September 17, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE – Firefighters and RHS JROTC cadets participated in a stair climb in recognition of the 24th anniversary of 9-11. Sgt. Grant Tarascou and...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *